At a recent homeschool conference, I picked up a book called “Don’t Make Me Count to
” by Ginger Plowman. In chapter 3, Drawing Out Issues of the Heart, she put forth an interesting solution to a common situation:
In the situation of siblings sharing….we wanted a solution that would be easy for them to understand and put into practice on their own. So, we came up with the rule that it is not only selfish but it is rude to take or even ask for something that someone else has until that person is obviously through with it.
Here is how the rule operates in our home. Suppose Wesley is playing with a toy. When Alex was younger, if she wanted it, she would just try to take it away. Now that she is older she might politely ask, “Wesley, may I please have that toy now?” If she attempts to take the toy, I usually respond with something like this:
“Honey, Wesley has that toy right now. Do you think he is enjoying playing with it?”
“Yes, ma’am.”
“Do you think it would make him happy or sad if you took it away?”
“Sad.”
“Would you delight in making your brother sad?”
“No, ma’am.”
“Do you think that it would be kind or rude for you to try to take away something that he is enjoying?”
“Rude.”
“That’s right, Alex, and love is not rude. When Wesley is through with it and puts it down, then you may ask for it.”
…This is the same behavior I would expect from adult friends or adult siblings. Look at it this way: If I were sitting across the table from you and someone handed me some pictures to look at that you, too, were interested in, would you wait until I was through to ask for them or would you ask to take them away when I had only just begun to enjoy looking at them? Most of us would agree that it would be rude to ask for them before I was finished.
Did you catch that? Ginger suggests that it’s rude to ask. And the more I think about it, the more sense it seems to make. Too often I think a child only wants what another has because the other has it. These ill-timed requests nearly always seem to have roots in covetousness, even when the request is politely done.
What do you think?











Recent Comments